A Finer End

he would expect such a quick resolution on an ordinary case, but he was frustrated both by his limited time and his lack of control over the investigation. Greely’s tactics were common enough — find the most likely suspect and bully him or her until you got a confession — but they certainly left much fertile ground unturned.
    And to complicate matters further, Jack was bringing Winnie home from hospital today. If she were still in danger, how much more vulnerable would she be now?
    He kept running aground on the same questions. Why had Andrew Catesby gone to see Garnet Todd? Why would someone other than Garnet have wanted to hurt — or kill — Winifred Catesby? If Garnet had not struck Winnie, where had she gone in the van that evening? And what had Winnie done in the hours she couldn’t remember?
    Some of the answers were undoubtedly locked within Winnie’s mind and could not be forced. And some of the questions were undoubtedly connected, if only he had some clue as to which ones they might be.
     
    Kincaid arrived at Jack’s to find Winnie installed on the sitting-room sofa, her lap filled with a jumble of papers.
    ‘That doesn’t look a proper convalescent project,’ Kincaid commented.
    Winnie smiled up at him. ‘I convinced Jack to start searching for the manuscript.’
    ‘He told you about Simon’s theory?’
    Nodding, she said, ‘And I think on this point Simon’s judgement should be trusted. Unfortunately, I’m not much help yet.’ She gestured at the papers in her lap. ‘This is the best I could do. But it would be easier if I knew exactly what I was looking for.’
    ‘How about a perfectly illuminated sheet of musical notation on parchment, with "The Lost Chant” at the top in Latin?’
    ‘And why don’t we have it rolled and tied with a red ribbon while we’re at it? Seriously, though, if we’ re not all completely mad, and if Edmund did make a copy of such a thing, it would have been on parchment. And how likely is it that something like that would have survived all those centuries without special care and handling?’
    ‘Simon seemed to think it was possible, and he’s the expert. Where’s Jack, then?’
    ‘Up in the attic, covered with dust and cobwebs. And swearing a blue streak, is my guess.’
    Kincaid grinned. ‘I expect you’re right. Why don’t you have a rest, and I’ll bring you a cuppa in a bit. How’s Faith?’
    ‘Holding up, but terribly worried about Nick. No one’s heard a word from him.’
    ‘I’ll go and have a chat with her.’
    He found Faith in the kitchen.
    ‘I see you managed to conjure up something to feed the masses,’ he told her, and was rewarded with a smile.
    ‘I made Jack run me to the supermarket this morning, before he went to collect Winnie. There’s fresh bread and roast beef, if you’d like a sandwich.’
    ‘I stopped on the way back from Bath, thanks.’ He pulled out a chair. ‘Are you not joining in the Great Treasure Hunt?’
    ‘I’m going in to the café until closing time. Buddy rang — he’s desperate for help. Sunday’s a big day, with all the weekend climbers.’ She watched him, her chin up, as if bracing to counter a negative reaction.
    ‘Are you sure you feel up to it?’ Kincaid asked gently.
    ‘I’m fine. And it’s only for a couple of hours.’
    ‘I’ll run you up to the café, then, and pick you up at closing—’
    ‘I can walk,’ she said acidly. ‘I’m pregnant, not crippled.’
    ‘Faith, it’s your safety I’m thinking about. Until we know more about what happened to Garnet — and to Winnie — I’d just as soon you didn’t go out on your own if it can be helped.’
    ‘Don’t tell me you think Nick—’
    ‘I didn’t say a word about Nick, and no, I don t think it’s likely that Nick had anything to do with Garnet’s death. But why do you suppose he hasn’t rung or come to the house?’
    Faith grasped the back of a chair. ‘I don’t know. That day, when he came into the café and said I should check Garnet’s front bumper... I was so furious. I told him to get out. But we’ve had rows before...’
    ‘You don’t think he’s still angry with you—’
    ‘And now, because of me, the police think he... I’d say he’s got good reason to be narked with me.’
    ‘I’m sure that’s not the case. But if you like, I’ll have a look for him after I drop you at the café.’
    ‘Could you?’
    ‘Any suggestions as to where, other than the caravan?’
    ‘He likes to go to