All the Pretty Horses

always had strange dreams. But I’m afraid they are quite independent of my dining habits.
    Yes mam.
    They have a long life, dreams. I have dreams now which I had as a young girl. They have an odd durability for something not quite real.
    Do you think they mean anything?
    She looked surprised. Oh yes, she said. Dont you?
    Well. I dont know. They’re in your head.
    She smiled again. I suppose I dont consider that to be the condemnation you do. Where did you learn to play chess?
    My father taught me.
    He must be a very good player.
    He was about the best I ever saw.
    Could you not win against him?
    Sometimes. He was in the war and after he come back I got to where I could beat him but I dont think his heart was in it. He dont play at all now.
    That’s a pity.
    Yes mam. It is.
    She poured their cups again.
    I lost my fingers in a shooting accident, she said. Shooting live pigeons. The right barrel burst. I was seventeen. Ajejandra’s age. There is nothing to be embarrassed about. People are curious. It’s only natural. I’m going to guess that the scar on your cheek was put there by a horse.
    Yes mam. It was my own fault.
    She watched him, not unkindly. She smiled. Scars have the strange power to remind us that our past is real. The events that cause them can never be forgotten, can they?
    No mam.
    Alejandra will be in Mexico with her mother for two weeks. Then she will be here for the summer.
    He swallowed.
    Whatever my appearance may suggest, I am not a particularly oldfashioned woman. Here we live in a small world. A close world. Alejandra and I disagree strongly. Quite strongly in fact. She is much like me at that age and I seem at times to be struggling with my own past self. I was unhappy as a child for reasons that are no longer important. But the thing in which we are united, my niece and I …
    She broke off. She set the cup and saucer to one side. The polished wood of the table held a round shape of breath where they’d stood that diminished from the edges in and vanished. She looked up.
    I had no one to advise me, you see. Perhaps I would not have listened anyway. I grew up in a world of men. I thought thiswould have prepared me to live in a world of men but it did not. I was also rebellious and so I recognize it in others. Yet I think that I had no wish to break things. Or perhaps only those things that wished to break me. The names of the entities that have power to constrain us change with time. Convention and authority are replaced by infirmity. But my attitude toward them has not changed. Has not changed.
    You see that I cannot help but be sympathetic to Alejandra. Even at her worst. But I wont have her unhappy. I wont have her spoken ill of. Or gossiped about. I know what that is. She thinks that she can toss her head and dismiss everything. In an ideal world the gossip of the idle would be of no consequence. But I have seen the consequences in the real world and they can be very grave indeed. They can be consequences of a gravity not excluding bloodshed. Not excluding death. I saw this in my own family. What Alejandra dismisses as a matter of mere appearance or outmoded custom …
    She made a whisking motion with the imperfect hand that was both a dismissal and a summation. She composed her hands again and looked at him.
    Even though you are younger than she it is not proper for you to be seen riding in the campo together without supervision. Since this was carried to my ears I considered whether to speak to Alejandra about it and I have decided not to.
    She leaned back. He could hear the clock ticking in the hall. There was no sound from the kitchen. She sat watching him.
    What do you want me to do? he said.
    I want you to be considerate of a young girl’s reputation.
    I never meant not to be.
    She smiled. I believe you, she said. But you must understand. This is another country. Here a woman’s reputation is all she has.
    Yes mam.
    There is no forgiveness, you see.
    Mam?
    There is no forgiveness. For women. A man may lose his honor and regain it again. But a woman cannot. She cannot.
    They sat. She watched him. He tapped the crown of his seated hat with the tips of his four fingers and looked up.
    I guess I’d have to say that that dont seem right.
    Right? she said. Oh. Yes. Well.
    She turned one hand in the air as if reminded of something she’d misplaced. No, she said. No. It’s not a matter of right. You must understand. It is a matter of who must say. In this matter I get to say. I am