Mourn not your Dead

down his pint and took the plunge. “All right, Nick, put us out of our misery quickly, then.”
    “You’ll never guess.” Deveney pulled down the knot on his tie and unbuttoned his collar. He’s ‘very anxious for a resolution,’ and he would be ‘most pleased’ if we were to find reason to charge Geoff Genovase with Gilbert’s murder. Allay any suspicion on the part of the public that we’re sitting around on our duffs, you know.”
    Gemma spluttered into her drink. “Is he daft? We don’t have a shred of evidence. Turning the burglary file over to the CPS is embarrassing enough—trying to bring a murder charge against him at this point would make us laughing-stocks.”
    “Not daft, politically minded,” snorted Deveney. “Gemma’s right, you know,” said Kincaid. “It’s all completely circumstantial, based on the assumption that Geoff might have taken Claire Gilbert’s earrings, which we did not find in his possession. For all we know she lost them or accidentally knocked them down the bloody drain in the lav.
    “We’ve checked his prints with the unknowns found in the Gilberts’ kitchen, and there’s not a smudge with a remote resemblance. Nor has forensics come up with any hair or fibers that might provide a link.”
    Deveney grinned. “So we assume that in the few minutes it took Geoff to download a file, he equipped himself with hat, gloves, and protective clothing, nipped across the road and killed the commander, then disposed of Claire’s earrings, the murder weapon, and the aforementioned protective clothing on his way back to the pub. Although, of course, we’ve searched every square inch in between and turned up sweet eff-all,” This brought a chorus of groans and much rolling of eyes. “Is that all the appreciation I get for a feat of intellectual daring?” Deveney winked at Gemma, and Kincaid saw her look quickly away.
    Before anyone could make a proper rejoinder, the barmaid brought their dinners. They tucked in like starving sailors, and for a while the clink of cutlery was the only sound at the table.
    Kincaid watched as Gemma ate her chips and plaice with quiet concentration. He was comforted simply by her proximity. She didn’t flinch if his knee occasionally brushed hers under the table, and he wondered if it heralded a thaw. Looking up at him, she gave him an unguarded smile, and he felt a wave of desire so strong it left him shaking.
    “You know,” said Deveney, pushing his plate away, “if that’s the chiefs line on this, maybe our village committee was right in refusing to throw Geoff to the wolves.”
    “So now we’re the wolves?” asked Kincaid a bit testily. “Would we let someone we thought innocent serve as a scapegoat?”
    “Of course not,” said Deveney, “but these political agendas can very easily get out of hand. We’ve all seen it happen.” He looked questioningly around the table and they all nodded grudging confirmation.
    Will wiped up the last bit of his shepherd’s pie with his last chip, then pushed his plate away and regarded them gravely. “It seems to me that we’re all mincing around the real question like little ballerinas. And that is, regardless of the nature of the evidence, do we think Geoff did it?”
    Watching his tablemates, Kincaid wondered fleetingly if the four of them were just as guilty of star-chamber behavior as the villagers. But they were all good, honest coppers, and none of them could do their jobs without exercising their judgment. Indecision would paralyze them. “No,” he said, breaking the silence. “I’d say it’s highly unlikely, at the very least, and I’ll not stand by and see him go down for a crime he didn’t commit.” Beside him, he felt Gemma relax as she nodded agreement, and Deveney followed suit. “Will?” Kincaid asked, unable to read the constable’s expression.
    “Oh, aye, I’d agree with you on that. It’s too tailor-made by half. But I wonder if we won’t wish we’d found such an easy solution by the time this is all over.” He drained his pint and added, “And what about Percy Bainbridge’s mysterious shadow?”
    Kincaid shrugged. “Could have been anybody.”
    “More likely a product of Percy’s imagination, dredged up purely for the drama,” said Deveney.
    “You’re not going to like this,” Gemma said slowly, “and I don’t like it either. But what if Gilbert went ferreting because he didn’t like his stepdaughter having a... relationship with Geoff? And