The Hard Way

actually. To celebrate our birthdays we were going to lose a foot. First choice, left or right. Second choice, long pants or short pants. That was a kind of joke. It meant we could be cut above the knee or below. Our choice. Third choice, we could use the bucket or not. Our choice. You plunge the stump in there, the boiling tar seals the arteries and cauterizes the wound. Choose not to, and you bleed out and die. Our choice. But the guard said we had to choose fast. We weren’t allowed to mess around and hold up the queue behind us.”
    Silence in the tiny room. Nobody spoke. There was no sound at all, except faint incongruous New York City sirens in the far distance.
    Hobart said, “I chose left, long pants, and yes to the bucket.”

CHAPTER 41
    FOR A LONG time the small room stayed quiet as a tomb. Hobart rolled his head from side to side to ease his neck. Reacher sat down in a small chair near the window.
    Hobart said, “Twelve months later on my next birthday I chose right, long pants, and yes to the bucket.”
    Reacher said, “They did this to Knight, too?”
    Hobart nodded. “We thought we had been close before. But some things really bring you together.”
    Pauling was leaning up in the kitchen doorway, white as a sheet. “Knight told you about Anne Lane?”
    “He told me about a lot of things. But remember, we were doing seriously hard time. We were sick and starving. We had infections. We had malaria and dysentery. We were out of our heads for weeks at a time with fevers.”
    “What did he tell you?”
    “He told me he shot Anne Lane in New Jersey.”
    “Did he tell you why?”
    “He gave me a whole bunch of different reasons. Different day, different reason. Sometimes it was that he had been having an affair with her, and she broke it off, and he got mad. Other times it was that Lane was mad at her and asked him to do it. Other times he said he was working for the CIA. Once he said she was an alien from another planet.”
    “Did he kidnap her?”
    Hobart nodded, slowly, painfully. “Drove her to the store, but didn’t stop there. Just pulled a gun and kept on going, all the way to New Jersey. Killed her there.”
    “Immediately?” Pauling asked.
    Hobart said, “Yes, immediately. She was dead a day before you ever even heard of her. There was nothing wrong with your procedures. He killed her that first morning and drove back and waited outside the store until it was time to sound the alarms.”
    “Not possible,” Pauling said. “His EZ-Pass records showed he hadn’t used a bridge or a tunnel that day.”
    “Give me a break,” Hobart said. “You pull the tag off the windshield and put it in the foil packet they mailed it in. Then you use a cash lane.”
    “Were you really in Philadelphia?” Reacher asked.
    “Yes, I really was,” Hobart said.
    “Did you know what Knight was doing that day?”
    “No, I really didn’t.”
    “Who faked Anne’s voice on the phone?” Pauling asked. “Who set up the ransom drop?”
    “Sometimes Knight would say it was a couple of his buddies. Sometimes he would say Lane took care of all of that.”
    “Which version did you believe?”
    Hobart’s head dropped to his chest and canted left. He stared toward the floor. Reacher asked, “Can I get you something?”
    “I’m just looking at your shoes,” Hobart said. “I like nice shoes, too. Or at least I did.”
    “You’ll get prosthetics. You can wear shoes with them.”
    “Can’t afford them. Prosthetics, or shoes.”
    Pauling said, “What was the truth about Anne Lane?”
    Hobart pulled his head back to the cushion so he could look straight up at Pauling. He smiled, sadly.
    “The truth about Anne Lane?” he said. “I thought about that a lot. Believe me, I obsessed over it. It became the central question of my life, because basically it was responsible for what was happening to me. The third birthday I spent in there, they took me back to the courtyard. The second choice was phrased slightly different. Long sleeves or short? Stupid question, really. Nobody ever chose short sleeves. I mean, who the hell would? I saw a thousand amputees in there and nobody ever took it above the elbow.”
    Silence in the room.
    “The things you remember,” Hobart said. “I remember the stink of the blood and the tar bucket and the pile of severed hands behind that big stone block. A bunch of black ones and one little white one.”
    Pauling asked, “What was the truth about Anne?”
    “The waiting