U Is for Undertow

I hung around downstairs. I got bored and asked if I could go outside. She said I could as long as I didn’t leave the property. I remember finding this tree with branches that hung down to make a little room, so I played there for a while, pretending I was a bandit in a cool hideout. I heard voices and when I peeped through the leaves, I saw the two guys walk by with shovels and stuff and I followed them.”
    “What time of day?”
    “Must have been late morning because after I came in again, the kid’s mother fed me lunch—a plain lettuce and tomato sandwich, no bacon, and it was made with Miracle Whip. Our family didn’t eat Miracle Whip. My mother wouldn’t have it in the house. She said it was disgusting compared to real homemade mayonnaise.”
    “Your mother made mayonnaise?”
    “The cook did.”
    “Ah.”
    “Anyway, Mom always said it was rude to complain, so I ate what I could and left the rest on my plate. The kid’s mom hadn’t even cut the crusts off the bread.”
    “There’s a shock,” I said. “I’m impressed your memory’s so clear.”
    “Not clear enough or I wouldn’t be here. I’m pretty sure the two guys I saw were the ones who abducted Mary Claire, but I have no idea where I was. I know I’d never been to the house before and I never went there again.”
    “Any chance one of your siblings would remember who the kid was?”
    “I guess it’s possible. Unfortunately, we don’t get along. We haven’t spoken in years.”
    “So you said.”
    “Sorry. I don’t mean to repeat myself. The point is, I can’t call them up out of a clear blue sky. Even if I did, I doubt they’d talk to me.”
    “But I could ask, couldn’t I? That would be the obvious first move if you’re serious about this.”
    He shook his head. “I don’t want them involved, especially my sister, Dee. She’s difficult. You don’t want to mess with her.”
    “All right. We’ll scratch that for now. Maybe the kid’s mother was being paid to babysit.”
    “That wasn’t my impression. More like she was doing Mom a favor.”
    “What about your classmates? Maybe she left you with one of the other moms, like a playdate.”
    Sutton blinked twice. “That’s a possibility I hadn’t thought of. I’ve kept in touch with the other two Michaels, Boorman and Trautwein, but that’s the extent of it. I didn’t like anybody else in my kindergarten class and they didn’t like me.”
    “It doesn’t matter if you liked them or not. We’re trying to identify the boy.”
    “I don’t remember anyone else.”
    “It should be easy enough to come up with a list. You must have had class photos. You could go back to the school library and check the ’67 yearbook.”
    “I don’t want to go back to Climp. I hate the idea.”
    “It’s just a suggestion. So far, we’re brainstorming,” I said. “Tell me about the two guys. How old would you say?”
    “I’m not sure. Older than my brothers, who were ten and twelve at the time, but not as old as my dad.”
    “Did they see you?”
    “Not then. I decided to spy on them, but where they ended up was too far away and I couldn’t see what they were doing. I sneaked up on them, crawling through the bushes and crouching behind a big oak. It was hot and they were sweating so they’d taken off their shirts. I guess I wasn’t as quiet as I thought because one of them spotted me and they both jumped. They stopped what they were doing and asked what I wanted.”
    “You actually talked to them?”
    “Oh, sure. Absolutely. We had this whole conversation. I thought they were pirates and I was all excited about meeting them.”
    “Pirates?”
    “My mother was reading me Peter Pan at bedtime, and I loved the illustrations. The pirates wore bandanas tied around their heads, which is what the two guys had done.”
    “Beards? Earrings? Eye patches?”
    That netted me a smile, but not much of one. He shook his head. “It was the bandanas that reminded me of pirates. I told them I knew that because of Peter Pan .”
    “What’d you talk about?”
    “First, I asked ’em if they were pirates for real and they told me they were. The one guy talked more than the other and when I asked what they were doing, he said they were digging for buried treasure . . .”
    As Sutton spoke, I could see him regressing to the little boy he’d been, earnest and easily impressed. He leaned forward in his chair. “I asked if the treasure was gold doubloons, but they said they didn’t