In the Midst of Life

apart by an explosion. Where his nose, mouth and chin should have been there was just a great, bloody hole. Still, he was alive, and his eyes moved, and his mind obviously worked, though he could not speak because he had no mouth or tongue. The surgeons patched him up; they grafted skin over the shrapnel wound, and he recovered. But he had been a handsome young man, and was now left with two eyes and a ghastly-looking hollow with a hole in it, and a tube in the hole, so that liquid foods could be passed into his stomach.’
    It was now my turn to gaze at
her
without speaking.
    ‘I was about eighteen, and like you I thought: “Why have they done this? Surely life with such a face, if you could call it a face, is worse than death.”’
    I did not know what to say. There was a knock at the door and the maid entered with a tray.
    ‘Thank you, Bertha. Put it here,please.’
    Matron poured tea.
    ‘These are deep and terrible subjects, Nurse, to which there can be no answers. I know you are upset, and I understand.’
    ‘That is a terrible story, Matron. I would not want to live with a face like that. What happened to him?’
    ‘He lives in an ex-servicemen’s home. He cannot live in the community, because everyone stares and points at him.’
    ‘So he is still alive! Is he happy?’
    ‘I do not know. He seems content – he is a gardener, and gardeners are always happy people. And he has a dog. When I was your age I thought as you do. You have just said: “I would not want to live with a face like that.” But I very much doubt if that man would say that he would rather be dead.’
    ‘But he was
young,
and he had a whole future in front of him, even with such an affliction. Mrs Ratski is old, she has come to the end of her life. She said she was going to die; she achieved what she wanted to do, and then said she was content to die. The obstruction in her intestines would have meant her suffering would have lasted only a few hours, and she would very likely have died in her son’s arms, like my granny died in my grandad’s arms.’
    ‘But the medical and nursing professions cannot allow anyone to die, if it can be prevented.’
    ‘But who are we doing it for? For the benefit of the patient, or the benefit of the medical profession? We say that the welfare of the patient comes first, but I am not so sure. The practice of medical skills and techniques seems to come first.’
    ‘I am certain that Mrs Ratski has been treated for the best of motives – to preserve life.’
    ‘But for the rest of her days she will be a decrepit old invalid who will be a burden to everyone!’
    ‘Human life is precious.’
    ‘And human death is sacred. Or at least it should be – and would be, if we allowed it to be. In the short experience I have had, sitting with the dying, I can say that the last few hours are always peaceful, almost spiritual. Wouldn’t you call that a sacred time?’
    ‘Yes, I agree, Nurse, and I have had thirty-five years of nursingexperience. I don’t really know what is meant by the term “death agony” because I have never seen it.’ She paused and thought, then added, ‘Perhaps, in a few people, I have seen what can be described as a struggle with death, and it can be distressing to behold. But for the vast majority of people death is gentle, tender.’
    ‘Well, it’s not like that for Mrs Ratski. The agony has been going on for five or six weeks, and it will continue. She has been deprived of a gentle death.’
    Matron said nothing, but I blundered on.
    ‘She thinks she is in a concentration camp, you know, and that we are using her as a guinea pig. She can’t understand what we are doing, or why. She is terrified all the time, terrified of
us.’
    ‘Yes, I know. That is something no one could have anticipated.’
    ‘But she has lived in fear, Matron, for weeks. It is tragic, terrible. I can’t bear to see it.’
    I was getting tearful, and had to stand up and walk about again. ‘And there’s another thing. All these injections she’s having. Dozens of them, daily. And now we’ve started paraldehyde. It’s mind-bending, Matron. It replaces one madness with another, different sort of madness.’
    I walked the length of the room and back, then sat down.
    And there is another thing that worries me, Matron. All this business about “she must have”. It is written in her notes. “If drugs are refused, to be injected.” And we, the nurses, have to inject them. It seems wrong.’
    A