West of Eden

boatmasters use."
    "But boats are almost as stupid as cloaks. All they ever learn to understand are just a few commands."
    "The technique is the same."
    "Good." Vaintè looked shrewdly out of the corner of her eyes and chose her words carefully. "Then you could teach an animal to understand and to speak?"
    "No, not to speak. To understand, yes, a few simple commands if the brain is big enough. But speaking requires vocal apparatus and areas of the brain that animals do not possess."
    "But I have heard animals talking."
    "Not talking, repeating sound patterns they have learned. Birds can do this."
    "No. I mean talking. Communicating with each other."
    "Impossible."
    "I am talking about fur animals. Filthy ustuzou."
    Enge began to understand the point that Vaintè was making and she signed her understanding. "Of course. If these creatures have some degree of intelligence—the fact that they use crude artifacts suggests that—why then, they might very well talk to each other. What an extraordinary thought. You have heard West of Eden - Harry Harrison
    them talk?"
    "I have. And so can you if you wish. We have two of them here." She waved over a passing fargi. "Find the hunter Stallan. Bring her to me at once."
    "How are the animals faring?" Vaintè asked when Stallan appeared.
    "I have had them washed, then I examined their injuries. Bruises, no more. I have also had the filth-ridden fur removed from their heads. The larger one is female, the smaller one a male. They drink water, but will eat nothing I have provided so far. But you must be careful if you get close to them."
    "I have no intention of doing that," Vaintè said, shivering with disgust. "It is Enge here who will approach them." Stallan turned to her.
    "You must face them at all times. Never turn your back on a wild animal. The small one bites, and they have claws, so I have manacled them for safety."
    "I will do as you say."
    "One other thing," Stallan said, taking a small sack from her harness and opening it. "When I cleaned the beasts I found this hung about the male's neck." She placed a small object on the table beside Vaintè.
    It was a blade of some kind, made of metal. There was an opening pierced at one end, while simple patterns had been scratched upon it. Vaintè poked at it with a tentative thumb.
    "It has been thoroughly cleaned," Stallan said. Vaintè picked it up and examined it closely.
    "The patterns are unfamiliar, as is the metal," she said, not liking what she saw. "Where did the animals find this? Who made the design? And the metal, where did they get that from? Do not try to tell me that they have the science to grow metal." She tested the edge against her skin. "Not sharp at all. What can it possibly mean?"
    There were no answers to these disturbing questions—nor had she expected any. She handed the bit of metal to Enge. "Another mystery for you to solve when you learn to speak to the creatures." Enge examined it and handed it back.
    "When may I see them?" she asked.
    "Now," Vaintè said. She signaled Stallan. "Take us to them."
    Stallan led the way through the corridors of the city, to a high, dark passage. Signaling for continuing West of Eden - Harry Harrison
    silence, she swung open a hatch set into the wall. Vaintè and Enge looked through into the chamber beyond. They could see that it was sealed by a single heavy door. There were no other openings and the only illumination was the feeble light that filtered down through a tough transparent sheet high above.
    Two repellent little creatures lay on the floor below. Tiny versions of the mutilated corpse that Enge had been forced to look at in the ambesed. Their skulls were bare and scratched where their fur had been removed. With the fur gone, and deprived of the stinking bits of skin that they had been bound about with, it could be seen that they were completely covered with repulsive, single-colored and waxy skin.
    The larger one, the female, was lying flat and making a repetitive wailing noise. The male squatted beside the female and emitted varied grunting sounds. This went on for a long time, until the wailing stopped.
    Then the female made other sounds as well. Vaintè signaled Stallan to close the hatch and leave.
    "It might be a kind of talking," Enge said, excited despite herself. "But they move very little when they make the sounds, which is very confusing. It will take much study. The whole concept is a novel one, a different language, the language of ustuzou, a