The Luminaries

us with our gold. It might just as well be the other way about. The greenstone rushes, we might call them. A greenrush, we might say.’
    Tauwhare thought about this, still chewing. After a moment he swallowed and shook his head. ‘No,’ he said.
    ‘There’s no difference,’ Wells insisted, reaching for another piece of meat. ‘You might not like it—but you have to admit—there’s no difference. It’s just one mineral or another. One rock or another.’
    ‘No,’ Tauwhare said. He looked angry. ‘It is not the same.’

PART TEN

Matters of Succession

DETRIMENT
    In which Anna Wetherell, who remembers the assault that occurred in the boudoir of the House of Many Wishes in Dunedin upon the night of the 12th of May with a stricken, nauseated clarity, and who is made wretched, daily, by the memory of that assault, a wretchedness not assuaged by the knowledge that her collusion, however tacit, helped an innocent man to escape unharmed, is surprised by the appearance of the disfigured man himself, and, in a moment of weakness, forgets herself
.
    Francis Carver was riding inland on the Kaniere-road when he spotted a familiar figure on the roadside. He reined in, dismounted his horse, and approached her, perceiving that her walk was unsteady and her face, very flushed. She was smiling.
    ‘He got away,’ she mumbled. ‘I helped him.’
    Carver came closer. He put his finger beneath her chin, and tilted her face. ‘Who?’
    ‘Crosbie.’
    Carver stiffened at once. ‘Wells,’ he said. ‘Where is he?’
    She hiccupped; suddenly she looked frightened.
    ‘Where?’ He pulled back and slapped her, hard, across the face. ‘Answer me. Is he here?’
    ‘No!’
    ‘In Otago? Canterbury? Where?’
    In desperation, she turned to run. Carver caught her by theshoulder, jerked her back—but just then there came the clap of gunshot, nearby—
    ‘Whoa,’ Carver shouted, spinning away—
    And the horse shied up—

FALL
    In which Anna Wetherell tells a falsehood to protect Crosbie Wells, attempting, in this belated act of loyalty, to atone for an earlier betrayal, the partial memory of which shifts and recedes, uncertainly, for her mind has been thrice fogged, once by smoke, a second time by violence, and lastly by the opiate administered by the physician Dr. Gillies, preparatory to a most unhappy procedure, during which Anna sobbed, and groaned, and clawed herself, becoming so distressed that Dr. Gillies was obliged to ask for help in restraining her, and Löwenthal, ordinarily a man of some fortitude in times of injury or upheaval, wept freely as he pried her hands away
.
    When Anna opened her eyes Löwenthal was standing over her, a white cloth in one hand, a jar of laudanum in the other; beside him stood Edgar Clinch, white-faced.
    ‘She’s awake,’ said Clinch.
    ‘Anna,’ Löwenthal said. ‘Anna. Dear heart.’
    ‘Mnh,’ she said.
    ‘Tell us what happened. Tell us who it was.’
    ‘Carver,’ she said thickly.
    ‘Yes?’ said Löwenthal, leaning in.
    She must not betray Crosbie Wells. She had sworn not to betray him. She must not mention his name.
    ‘Carver …’ she said again, her mind focusing, unfocusing.
    ‘Yes?’
    ‘… Was the father,’ Anna said.

THE DESCENDANT
    In which Emery Staines, learning of Anna’s assault from Benjamin Löwenthal, saddles up at once and rides for the Arahura Valley, his jaw set, his eyes pricking tears, these being the external tokens of an emotional disturbance for which he does not, over the course of the journey north, admit true cause, much less attempt to articulate, inasmuch as any powerful emotion can be immediately articulated or understood by the sufferer, who, in this case, had been so distressed by Löwenthal’s frank account of the injuries sustained, and by the blood that soaked his printer’s apron from chest to hip, that he forgot both his wallet and his hat at the stables, and as he rode out, almost charged down Harald Nilssen as the latter exited Tiegreen’s Hardware with a paper sack beneath his arm
.
    Wells opened his door. There upon the threshold, doubled over, was Emery Staines.
    ‘The baby’s gone,’ he sobbed. ‘Your baby’s gone.’
    Wells helped him inside, and listened to the story. Then he fetched a bottle of brandy, poured them each a glassful, downed it, poured them each another, downed it, poured them a third.
    When the bottle was empty Staines said, ‘I’ll give her half. I’ll share it with her. I’ve a